Use jelly beans, coffee beans, or chocolate-covered coffee beans. Wrap them in saran wrap or place in the tiny ziploc baggies. Attach the tag with ribbons.

Seal and label with the following poem, or print some free printable Turkey Poop Gift Tags:

You invited me to dinner
with your family and your friends.
You didn't say I was the main dish.
For me it was "THE END!"

You frightened me so badly
I knew I had been duped!
So I left you with my calling card:
This bag of Turkey Poop!