Use candy corn or black & orange jelly babies. Wrap them in saran wrap or place in the tiny ziploc baggies. Attach the tag with ribbons.

Seal and label with the following poem, or print some free printable Pumpkin Poop Gift Tags:

I started to carve a pumpkin
with my carving knife and scoop
But the pumpkin got so scared
He took a little poop!

It looked so cute and funny
Just like a candy treat
So I'm sharing it with you now
Because you are so sweet!